Today’s CRE market looks different from the downturns of the past — and the risks have changed with it.
Following over a year of decline in construction spending, US Nonresidential Construction is nearing an inflection point. Commercial banks are accelerating their lending in the commercial real estate (CRE) space. With construction moving toward recovery, it begs the question: have we moved beyond the CRE downturn, or are financial risks still waiting ahead?
The data suggests that the worst fears of a broad CRE financial crisis have not materialized and that today's lending environment looks considerably different from the run-up to the Great Recession. However, the risks have not disappeared, and outcomes are highly uneven depending what segment of CRE you look at. For example, US Private Data Center Construction was 38.5% above year-ago levels in August amid an ongoing surge in AI investment. This contrasts sharply with US Private Office Construction (Excluding Data Centers), which has fallen approximately 30% in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. Meanwhile, Warehouse Construction and Education Construction are below year-ago levels, but they are signaling early signs of improvement.
Given interest rate pressures and that the significantly weaker economic environment of the 2030s is looming increasingly large in the windshield, investors should take steps to prepare for the downturn.
The clearest vulnerability lies not in loans being originated today, but in older loans approaching maturity. Debt yields illustrate the difference: Trepp reported an average debt yield of 8.77% for the 2021 CMBS vintage versus 10.36% for 2026, meaning today's newly securitized loans generally have more property income supporting each dollar of debt. At the same time, higher interest rates have reduced debt-service coverage because borrowers must devote more of that income to interest and principal payments.
That creates refinancing risk. A property financed at a low rate several years ago may still generate adequate income but be unable to support the same loan balance at today's borrowing costs. The Mortgage Bankers Association estimates that approximately $875 billion of commercial and multifamily mortgage balances, or 17% of outstanding commercial mortgages, are maturing in 2026. Longer term, investors should not lose sight of the increased risks that high interest rates pose. If incomes drop and vacancies rise as we expect in the economic turmoil of the 2030s, we will likely see a wave of CRE defaults and lower asset prices.
The evidence increasingly points toward recovery rather than an approaching system-wide CRE crisis. LTVs remain below pre-Great-Recession extremes, new loans generally have strong debt yields, private-label securitization represents a smaller share of the market, and financing availability is accelerating. Yet the recovery will not be uniform across property types, and legacy loans still face lower valuations and substantially higher refinancing costs.
The bottom line: The makeup of the CRE market has changed meaningfully, and while the CRE market has proven relatively resilient to higher rates overall, longer term those risks have ratcheted up. Overall, CRE appears to be moving beyond its most acute period of financial stress, but the adjustment is not over. For businesses tied to nonresidential construction, the improving availability of credit backdrop is encouraging; the key risk to be watching is how successfully the market works through older debt as it matures. We urge investors to focus on preparing their CRE profile to withstand the significant pressures the 2030s will pose to investments — if you need help assessing your property portfolio’s exposure, reach out to us.